What Is Fantasy Editing?
A book is more than just text—especially in the fantasy genre. It's not just about correct grammar, but about magic, atmosphere, and emotional depth. A fantasy edit should preserve all that: the author’s voice, the magic of words, the uniqueness of the world. Unfortunately, the opposite often happens. Many edits—usually well-intentioned—approach a manuscript through an academic, analytical lens and lose the heart of the story in the process. But what exactly makes a good fantasy edit? And what should self-publishers look out for when revising their manuscript? This article offers insight into the challenges—and opportunities—of editing in the fantasy space.
Merchandise
Why Fantasy Is Special
Fantasy is a genre of endless possibilities. Magic, distant worlds, ancient races, epic journeys—nothing is off limits. But this creative freedom comes with unique demands. The language is often more lyrical, the sentence structure more fluid, the narrative more complex. Authors draw from mythology, philosophy, and personal vision—their texts thrive on stylistic quirks, striking imagery, and deep emotional expression.
An edit that adheres too strictly to standard writing or marketing rules risks flattening those nuances. What remains may be technically correct, but lifeless. That’s why fantasy editing requires more than corrections: it demands an understanding of storytelling, atmosphere, and individuality—and the skill to grasp the heart of a work instead of forcing it into a mold.
The Problem: Flattened Instead of Shaped
Many self-publishers report frustration after hiring an editor. Not because they didn’t expect critique—but because the final result barely resembles their original work. What was once a passionate manuscript with texture and personality becomes a streamlined, standardized version—readable, yes, but no longer authentic.
A common scenario: the author has developed a playful, expressive writing style full of metaphor, rhythm, and emotion. But the editor wants to tighten, standardize, and make it “marketable.” Dialogues are trimmed, descriptions neutralized, unique quirks erased. In the end, the author feels like a stranger to their own story.
Rules are important—no question. But in fantasy, there’s more at stake. A good fantasy edit should not feel like a technical inspection; it should protect the magic that makes the story special. It’s not about conforming to style norms—it’s about shaping and preserving a unique voice with care.
Event Calender overview
What Makes a Good Fantasy Edit
A good fantasy editor doesn’t work against the author’s style—they work with it. They recognize that an unusual sentence structure may not be a mistake, but a deliberate choice. That magic doesn’t just live in the plot, but also in the language. That an epic world-building effort may need more explanation than a contemporary short story.
A skilled fantasy editor understands genre structures, recognizes archetypes, and senses emotional resonance. Instead of blindly trimming or standardizing, they assess whether a stylistic choice enhances the story—or hinders the reader’s journey.
Good fantasy editors provide:
- Style-sensitive feedback rather than rewriting by formula
- Suggestions for world-building consistency, magic systems, and timelines
- Input on narrative rhythm and emotional impact
- Dialogue on equal footing, not top-down evaluation
This transforms editing from a corrective process into a creative partnership—one that enhances a manuscript without losing its essence.
Tips for Self-Publishers
If you're seeking a fantasy editor, be strategic—not every editor suits every book. Here are a few tips:
- Start with a sample edit: Have 2–3 pages edited first to see if your style is understood.
- Ask about fantasy experience: Has the editor worked on fantasy manuscripts before?
- Clarify your expectations: Do you want style revisions or just help with logic and plot?
- Insist on communication: A good editor asks questions and explains their suggestions.
- Trust your instincts: Do you feel understood—or simply corrected?
In self-publishing, your writing style is your signature. Losing it means losing what makes you unique. That’s why the right editor isn’t just about polish—it’s about protecting your creative integrity.
Perspective Shift: What Editors Need
Editors are under pressure too. They’re expected to find mistakes, improve the text, be client-friendly and efficient. And not every author handles feedback well—misunderstandings are common. That’s why open dialogue is crucial.
If you, as an author, clearly express what matters to you—your style, your message, your readers—an editor can respond accordingly. Rather than drawing battle lines, you can build a partnership where both sides grow. That’s what makes editing valuable: not as a system of correction, but as a shared creative journey.
get your free Abo
Conclusion Fantasy Edit
A fantasy edit can make a manuscript shine—or drain it of its magic. The difference doesn’t lie in rules, but in understanding. Fantasy is freedom, voice, emotion. That’s why it deserves editing that strengthens rather than standardizes.
📣 Are you a self-publisher? Share your editing experiences in the comments!
📩 Know an editor who truly understands fantasy? Tag them—we’d love to feature them!
Read more exciting Fantasy News!
Support subscription (1.99€)
🖤Did you enjoy this article?
Support the magazine with a voluntary subscription – starting at just €1.99/month. Every contribution helps!
